| Year | Where it was hidden | Who found it |
|---|---|---|
| 1972 | Half planted in one of the flower pots behind the Social Hall. | Scott Blechner |
| 1973 | Between two branches of a tree near the road between Boys Arts and Crafts and Wayne Hall. | Paul Harnick |
| 1974 | Under the steps leading up to the roadside door of the social hall dressing room. | |
| 1975 | Inside of a hollow fence post, in front of the girls side of the dining room, which had a secret removable panel. | Artie Sunshine and Brenda Tinges (Judges) |
| 1976 | Attached to the undercarriage of Al Arbuse's truck. | |
| 1977 | Hidden inside a fencepost along the edge of camp near the front gate. | |
| 1978 | Hidden inside a hollow log, near the campsite between the Girls' waterfront and the dinning room. | Lauren Frank |
| 1979 | In a rolled up snow fence, stashed in the woods behind the girls side infirmary. | Robert Schenker |
| 1980 | In the Apple tree, between the Canteen and Wayne Hall, hung from a wire and suspended inside of a huge, deep hollow 7 feet off the ground. | |
| 1981 | Hidden inside a hollow log. | Ira Platt |
| 1983? | Inside a pump-can of "bug spray" solution, which was actually blue liquid, with a hint of pine oil. | Non-Participant |
| 1984 | In the hole of a tree right near the boys waterfront bbq site. | Neil Roth |
| 1985 | In a tree, by the archery area. | |
| 1986 | Under a bunch of brush by the fence by the front gate. | |
| 1988 | In a log, along the road past the boys waterfront, on the way to the pit. | Pippa Mayell |
| 1989 | In a log, in the woods on the Waterskiing hill.(Behind Girls 4) | |
| 1990 | Behind the ropeburn area in a pipe on the ground. (Where the horses are now) | Michael Bongino |
| 1993 | In a hollowed part of the tree between Wayne Hall and the canteen. | Corey Goodman |
| 1994 | On Big Al's golf cart between hockey pads. | Scott Weisenthal |
| 1995 | In a log in "Little Al's" goat pen. | Jason Halverson and Andrew Weinman |
| 1996 | Under a propane tank, behind Boys bunk 1 (Old Boys Infirmary), behind an extra cinderblock. | Taryn Green and Cara Kogel |
| 1997 | In the rusted box at the bottom of the fireplace outside of the dinning room. | Jason Horowitz and Stephanie Lowenthal |
| 1998 | Nailed between 2 logs, down by the bbq site, near the Pavilion. | Marc Silber |
| 1999 | In the corner gutter on the back porch of the social hall, above the water fountain. | Clay Wortman |
| 2000 | Partially buried within a dirt mound on a small construction site directly to the right side of Wayne Hall. | Jason Senzon |
| 2001 | Hidden beneath the ledge of the cooking (nature) shack porch, buried within tall grass. | Daniel Kamhi |
| 2002 | Buried underneath a hot water heater, hidden within the "goat shed", adjacent to the cooking (nature) shack. | Jared
Gruszecki with Brian Cowan, Ian Dorfman, Brendan Kahn, Michael Schechner and Michael Phillips |
| 2003 | Hidden underneath Big Al's old golf cart, which was situated directly next to the dining room. | Lauren Kasnett |
| 2004 | Hanging from a nail behind girls bunk 7 | Raf Turnball |
| 2005 | Attached to bungee cords hidden underneath the new blue tractor, parked adjacent to the dining room. |
Billy Shuster with Jordan Silber & Adam Saks |
| 2006 | In the bushes along the road by the football field, in the north end of the end zone. | Rick Goldstein with Andrew "Sox" Braunstein, Brad Bernstein, Jared Brown & Cody Rose |
| 2007 | Buried in a hole by the roots of a tree near the new Gymnastics Pavilion. | Billy Shuster |
| 2008 | In the rain gutter to the left of the social hall water fountain (above the weight room), accessible by a ladder located by the scoreboard. | Adam Ross |
| 2009 | On the red garbage tractor on the trailer located by the boys side of the dining room closest to the BBQ area. It was at the bottom of a box of black garbage bags wrapped up in its own black garbage bag. | Amanda Rovitz, Alexa Fox & Erika Surbaugh |
| 2010 | In a laundry bucket on the porch of Boys Bunk 7 | Matt Steinberg, Justin Clark & Chris Larrison |
| 2011 | Hidden inside an archery target | Senior girl counselor CJ and co-counselor Perri Prosky, with campers Joley Schneider, Kasey Roberts, Tori Lopis, and Ryan Engelhardt | 2012 | Hidden under a bench behind Girls bunks 7 & 8 | CIT's Sammi Kaplan & Jen Davis | 2013 | Inside a Gatorade cooler, on the small soccer field adjacent to the Dome. | Harrison Roth |